Statement on Higgins Lake Special Assessment District Appeal Ruling
For Immediate Release | October 15, 2026
https://olcplc.com/public/media?1792104730
Today, the Roscommon County Circuit Court ruled in favor of Roscommon and Crawford Counties in the Higgins Lake special assessment case. We respectfully and strongly disagree with the decision.
The Michigan and U.S. Supreme Courts have established that special assessments must be reasonably related to the actual benefits received by property owners.
For the Higgins Lake Special Assessment District, county officials never determined what actual benefit their expenditures would provide to any property. They simply calculated their expenses and divided those costs among property owners.
Judge Robert Bennett ruled against the property owners because they had not shown their assessments exceeded the benefits received.
That is backwards and looks at only half the equation. The decision completely overlooked the other half. The Counties never established what those benefits were in the first place.
OLC believes this was a fundamental legal error. Government should not be allowed to charge property owners without first establishing the special benefits that justify those charges and call it a special assessment.
We will appeal this decision to the Michigan Court of Appeals.
###